Difference between revisions of "1992 AIME Problems/Problem 13"

Latest revision as of 22:13, 30 August 2024

Problem

Triangle $ABC$ has $AB=9$ and $BC: AC=40: 41$ . What's the largest area that this triangle can have?

Solution

Solution 1

First, consider the triangle in a coordinate system with vertices at $(0,0)$ , $(9,0)$ , and $(a,b)$ . Applying the distance formula, we see that $\frac{ \sqrt{a^2 + b^2} }{ \sqrt{ (a-9)^2 + b^2 } } = \frac{40}{41}$ .

We want to maximize $b$ , the height, with $9$ being the base.

Simplifying gives $-a^2 -\frac{3200}{9}a +1600 = b^2$ .

To maximize $b$ , we want to maximize $b^2$ . So if we can write: $b^2=-(a+n)^2+m$ , then $m$ is the maximum value of $b^2$ (this follows directly from the trivial inequality, because if ${x^2 \ge 0}$ then plugging in $a+n$ for $x$ gives us ${(a+n)^2 \ge 0}$ ).

$b^2=-a^2 -\frac{3200}{9}a +1600=-\left(a +\frac{1600}{9}\right)^2 +1600+\left(\frac{1600}{9}\right)^2$ .

$\Rightarrow b\le\sqrt{1600+\left(\frac{1600}{9}\right)^2}=40\sqrt{1+\frac{1600}{81}}=\frac{40}{9}\sqrt{1681}=\frac{40\cdot 41}{9}$ .

Then the area is $9\cdot\frac{1}{2} \cdot \frac{40\cdot 41}{9} = \boxed{820}$ .

Solution 2

Let the three sides be $9,40x,41x$ , so the area is $\frac14\sqrt {(81^2 - 81x^2)(81x^2 - 1)}$ by Heron's formula. By AM-GM, $\sqrt {(81^2 - 81x^2)(81x^2 - 1)}\le\frac {81^2 - 1}2$ , and the maximum possible area is $\frac14\cdot\frac {81^2 - 1}2 = \frac18(81 - 1)(81 + 1) = 10\cdot82 = \boxed{820}$ . This occurs when $81^2 - 81x^2 = 81x^2 - 1\implies x = \frac {\sqrt {3281}}9$ .

Comment

Rigorously, we need to make sure that the equality of the AM-GM inequality is possible to be obtained (in other words, $(81^2 - 81x^2)$ and $(81x^2 - 1)$ can be equal with some value of $x$ ). MAA is pretty good at generating smooth combinations, so in this case, the AM-GM works; however, always try to double check in math competitions -- the writer of Solution 2 gave us a pretty good example of checking if the AM-GM equality can be obtained. ~Will_Dai

Solution 3

Let $A, B$ be the endpoints of the side with length $9$ . Let $\Gamma$ be the Apollonian Circle of $AB$ with ratio $40:41$ ; let this intersect $AB$ at $P$ and $Q$ , where $P$ is inside $AB$ and $Q$ is outside. Then because $(A, B; P, Q)$ describes a harmonic set, $AP/AQ=BP/BQ\implies \dfrac{\frac{41}{9}}{BQ+9}=\dfrac{\frac{40}{9}}{BQ}\implies BQ=360$ . Finally, this means that the radius of $\Gamma$ is $\dfrac{360+\frac{40}{9}}{2}=180+\dfrac{20}{9}$ .

Since the area is maximized when the altitude to $AB$ is maximized, clearly we want the last vertex to be the highest point of $\Gamma$ , which just makes the altitude have length $180+\dfrac{20}{9}$ . Thus, the area of the triangle is $\dfrac{9\cdot \left(180+\frac{20}{9}\right)}{2}=\boxed{820}$

Solution 4 (Involves Basic Calculus)

We can apply Heron's on this triangle after letting the two sides equal $40x$ and $41x$ . Heron's gives

$\sqrt{\left(\frac{81x+9}{2} \right) \left(\frac{81x-9}{2} \right) \left(\frac{x+9}{2} \right) \left(\frac{-x+9}{2} \right)}$ .

This can be simplified to

$\frac{9}{4} \cdot \sqrt{(81x^2-1)(81-x^2)}$ .

We can optimize the area of the triangle by finding when the derivative of the expression inside the square root equals 0.

We have that $-324x^3+13124x=0$ , so $x=\frac{\sqrt{3281}}{9}$ .

Plugging this into the expression, we have that the area is $\boxed{820}$ .

$\textbf{-RootThreeOverTwo}$

~minor $\LaTeX$ edit by Yiyj1

Solution 5

We can start how we did above in solution 4 to get $\frac{9}{4} * \sqrt{(81x^2-1)(81-x^2)}$ . Then, we can notice the inside is a quadratic in terms of $x^2$ , which is $-81(x^2)^2+6562x^2-81$ . This is maximized when $x^2 = \frac{3281}{81}$ .If we plug it into the equation, we get $\frac{9}{4} \cdot \frac{3280}{9} = \boxed{820}$

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
 == Problem ==
-Triangle <math>ABC^{}_{}</math> has <math>AB=9^{}_{}</math> and <math>BC: AC=40: 41^{}_{}</math>. What's the largest area that this triangle can have?
+Triangle <math>ABC</math> has <math>AB=9</math> and <math>BC: AC=40: 41</math>. What's the largest area that this triangle can have?
 == Solution ==
-{{solution}}
+===Solution 1===
+First, consider the [[triangle]] in a [[coordinate system]] with [[vertex|vertices]] at <math>(0,0)</math>, <math>(9,0)</math>, and <math>(a,b)</math>. Applying the [[distance formula]], we see that <math>\frac{ \sqrt{a^2 + b^2} }{ \sqrt{ (a-9)^2 + b^2 } } = \frac{40}{41}</math>.
+We want to maximize <math>b</math>, the height, with <math>9</math> being the base.
+Simplifying gives <math>-a^2 -\frac{3200}{9}a +1600 = b^2</math>.
+To maximize <math>b</math>, we want to maximize <math>b^2</math>. So if we can write: <math>b^2=-(a+n)^2+m</math>, then <math>m</math> is the maximum value of <math>b^2</math> (this follows directly from the [[trivial inequality]], because if <math>{x^2 \ge 0}</math> then plugging in <math>a+n</math> for <math>x</math> gives us <math>{(a+n)^2 \ge 0}</math>).
+<math>b^2=-a^2 -\frac{3200}{9}a +1600=-\left(a +\frac{1600}{9}\right)^2 +1600+\left(\frac{1600}{9}\right)^2</math>.
+<math>\Rightarrow b\le\sqrt{1600+\left(\frac{1600}{9}\right)^2}=40\sqrt{1+\frac{1600}{81}}=\frac{40}{9}\sqrt{1681}=\frac{40\cdot 41}{9}</math>.
+Then the area is <math>9\cdot\frac{1}{2} \cdot \frac{40\cdot 41}{9} = \boxed{820}</math>.
+===Solution 2===
+Let the three sides be <math>9,40x,41x</math>, so the area is <math>\frac14\sqrt {(81^2 - 81x^2)(81x^2 - 1)}</math> by Heron's formula. By AM-GM, <math>\sqrt {(81^2 - 81x^2)(81x^2 - 1)}\le\frac {81^2 - 1}2</math>, and the maximum possible area is <math>\frac14\cdot\frac {81^2 - 1}2 = \frac18(81 - 1)(81 + 1) = 10\cdot82 = \boxed{820}</math>. This occurs when <math>81^2 - 81x^2 = 81x^2 - 1\implies x = \frac {\sqrt {3281}}9</math>.
+====Comment====
+Rigorously, we need to make sure that the equality of the AM-GM inequality is possible to be obtained (in other words, <math>(81^2 - 81x^2)</math> and <math>(81x^2 - 1)</math> can be equal with some value of <math>x</math>). MAA is pretty good at generating smooth combinations, so in this case, the AM-GM works; however, always try to double check in math competitions -- the writer of Solution 2 gave us a pretty good example of checking if the AM-GM equality can be obtained.   ~Will_Dai
+===Solution 3===
+Let <math>A, B</math> be the endpoints of the side with length <math>9</math>. Let <math>\Gamma</math> be the Apollonian Circle of <math>AB</math> with ratio <math>40:41</math>; let this intersect <math>AB</math> at <math>P</math> and <math>Q</math>, where <math>P</math> is inside <math>AB</math> and <math>Q</math> is outside. Then because <math>(A, B; P, Q)</math> describes a harmonic set, <math>AP/AQ=BP/BQ\implies \dfrac{\frac{41}{9}}{BQ+9}=\dfrac{\frac{40}{9}}{BQ}\implies BQ=360</math>. Finally, this means that the radius of <math>\Gamma</math> is <math>\dfrac{360+\frac{40}{9}}{2}=180+\dfrac{20}{9}</math>.
+Since the area is maximized when the altitude to <math>AB</math> is maximized, clearly we want the last vertex to be the highest point of <math>\Gamma</math>, which just makes the altitude have length <math>180+\dfrac{20}{9}</math>. Thus, the area of the triangle is <math>\dfrac{9\cdot \left(180+\frac{20}{9}\right)}{2}=\boxed{820}</math>
+===Solution 4 (Involves Basic Calculus)===
+We can apply Heron's on this triangle after letting the two sides equal <math>40x</math> and <math>41x</math>. Heron's gives
+<math>\sqrt{\left(\frac{81x+9}{2} \right) \left(\frac{81x-9}{2} \right) \left(\frac{x+9}{2} \right) \left(\frac{-x+9}{2} \right)}</math>.
+This can be simplified to
+<math>\frac{9}{4} \cdot \sqrt{(81x^2-1)(81-x^2)}</math>.
+We can optimize the area of the triangle by finding when the derivative of the expression inside the square root equals 0.
+We have that <math>-324x^3+13124x=0</math>, so <math>x=\frac{\sqrt{3281}}{9}</math>.
+Plugging this into the expression, we have that the area is <math>\boxed{820}</math>.
+<math>\textbf{-RootThreeOverTwo}</math>
+~minor <math>\LaTeX</math> edit by Yiyj1
+===Solution 5 ===
+We can start how we did above in solution 4 to get
+<math>\frac{9}{4} * \sqrt{(81x^2-1)(81-x^2)}</math>.
+Then, we can notice the inside is a quadratic in terms of <math>x^2</math>, which is
+<math>-81(x^2)^2+6562x^2-81</math>. This is maximized when <math>x^2 = \frac{3281}{81}</math>.If we plug it into the equation, we get <math>\frac{9}{4} \cdot \frac{3280}{9} = \boxed{820}</math>
 == See also ==
-* [[1992 AIME Problems/Problem 12 | Previous Problem]]
+{{AIME box|year=1992|num-b=12|num-a=14}}
-* [[1992 AIME Problems/Problem 14 | Next Problem]]
-* [[1992 AIME Problems]]
+[[Category:Intermediate Geometry Problems]]
+{{MAA Notice}}

1992 AIME (Problems • Answer Key • Resources)
Preceded by Problem 12	Followed by Problem 14
1 • 2 • 3 • 4 • 5 • 6 • 7 • 8 • 9 • 10 • 11 • 12 • 13 • 14 • 15
All AIME Problems and Solutions

Page

Toolbox

Search